IATF 16949:2016 Clause 8.3.3.2 Manufacturing process design input

Manufacturing process design is the systematic planning and optimization of the processes involved in transforming raw materials or components into finished products. It encompasses a series of activities that aim to create an efficient, cost-effective, and reliable production system. During the manufacturing process design, various factors are considered, including product specifications, design requirements, material characteristics, production volumes, and quality standards. The goal is to develop a detailed road map that outlines the sequence of operations, the use of machinery and equipment, workforce allocation, quality control measures, and testing protocols. By carefully designing the manufacturing process, organizations can enhance productivity, reduce waste and defects, ensure product consistency, and meet customer demands effectively. Moreover, process design also plays a vital role in optimizing resource utilization, reducing production lead times, and maintaining compliance with industry regulations and standards. Continuous improvement efforts based on data analysis and feedback further enhance the effectiveness and efficiency of the manufacturing process, contributing to the organization’s overall success and competitiveness in the market.There are specific requirements for manufacturing process design. The manufacturing process design inputs include:

1. Product Design Information: Manufacturing process design starts with detailed product design information, including specifications, drawings, and requirements. Clear and complete product design information is crucial for developing the manufacturing process.
2. Design for Manufacturing (DFM) and Design for Assembly (DFA) Considerations: The organization should consider DFM and DFA principles to optimize the manufacturing process and ensure that the product is designed in a way that is easy to manufacture and assemble.
3. Process Flow Diagrams: Process flow diagrams illustrate the sequence of steps involved in the manufacturing process. These diagrams help identify potential bottlenecks and optimize the production sequence.
4. Process Failure Mode and Effects Analysis (PFMEA): PFMEA is used to identify potential failure modes in the manufacturing process and their effects. This helps in developing appropriate risk mitigation strategies.
5. Control Plan: The Control Plan outlines the control measures and activities to be implemented at various stages of the manufacturing process to ensure product quality and consistency.
6. Work Instructions: Work instructions provide detailed step-by-step guidelines for workers to follow during the manufacturing process. These instructions ensure consistency and reduce the risk of errors.
7. Equipment and Tooling Specifications: Specifications for machinery, equipment, and tooling used in the manufacturing process should be defined to ensure they meet the required standards.
8. Validation of Manufacturing Processes: The organization must validate the manufacturing processes to ensure that they are capable of producing products that meet customer requirements and quality standards.
9. Measurement Systems Analysis (MSA): MSA is used to assess the accuracy and reliability of measurement systems used in the manufacturing process.
10. Statistical Process Control (SPC): SPC techniques are used to monitor and control the variability in the manufacturing process, ensuring that it operates within specified limits.
11. Special Characteristics Identification and Control: Special characteristics of the product and process should be identified, and appropriate control measures should be implemented to ensure their compliance with requirements.
12. Risk Management: The organization must assess risks associated with the manufacturing process and develop strategies to mitigate these risks.

By addressing these manufacturing process design inputs, organizations can ensure that their manufacturing processes are capable of consistently producing high-quality products that meet customer requirements and comply with industry standards.

Clause 8.3.3.2 Manufacturing process design input

The organization are to identify, document, and review manufacturing process design input requirements including product design output data including special characteristics; targets for productivity, process capability, timing, and’ cost; manufacturing technology alternatives; customer requirements, if any; experience from previous developments; new materials; product handling and ergonomic requirements; and design for manufacturing and design for assembly. Use of error proofing method to be included in the manufacturing process design to a degree appropriate to the magnitude of the problem(s) and commensurate with the risks encountered.

You must identify, document and review manufacturing process design input that include – product design output data; targets for productivity; process capability and cost; customer requirements for manufacturing, if any; and experience from past Design and Development projects and manufacturing activities; and the use of error-proofing methods appropriate to the size of problems and risks experienced. You must have a process to deploy (identify, document, review and use) manufacturing process design input information coming from various sources. Use a Project Schedule to manage the planning work. Input generally include: design objectives (output and specs summary of customer. Statutory, Regulatory and own requirements), customer schedule, lessons learned, product drawings and/or specs. Lessons learnt are from internal manufacturing records, FMEA history etc. Some OEM customers requires continuous recording during operations. This makes things easier when developing new parts. If your organization is making the product for the first time, the customer should be able to furnish lessons learned. Functional tests on products are still required, but expected to be much less as compared to product design. The organization can identify and review manufacturing process design input requirements through a systematic and collaborative approach. Here’s a step-by-step guide to this process:

1. Product Design Collaboration: Establish close collaboration between product design teams and manufacturing engineers. This ensures that the design team understands the manufacturing constraints and opportunities, allowing them to provide relevant and feasible input requirements.
2. Cross-Functional Meetings: Organize cross-functional meetings involving representatives from product design, manufacturing, quality, and other relevant departments. These meetings facilitate discussions to gather input requirements from different stakeholders.
3. Analysis of Product Design Information: Thoroughly analyze product design information, such as specifications, drawings, and requirements, to extract necessary data for the manufacturing process.
4. Design for Manufacturing (DFM) and Design for Assembly (DFA) Analysis: Apply DFM and DFA principles to identify specific manufacturing requirements and considerations that should be addressed in the process design.
5. Process Flow Development: Develop a detailed process flow diagram to outline the sequence of operations and identify the input requirements for each step of the manufacturing process.
6. Failure Mode and Effects Analysis (FMEA): Conduct a PFMEA to identify potential failure modes in the manufacturing process and determine the input requirements for risk mitigation.
7. Control Plan Development: Develop a Control Plan that outlines the control measures, inspection points, and testing protocols required to ensure product quality and consistency.
8. Work Instructions Preparation: Prepare work instructions that provide clear and detailed guidelines for workers to follow during the manufacturing process.
9. Validation of Manufacturing Processes: Perform validation activities to verify that the manufacturing processes are capable of producing products that meet customer requirements and quality standards.
10. Measurement Systems Analysis (MSA): Conduct MSA to assess the accuracy and reliability of measurement systems used in the manufacturing process.
11. Statistical Process Control (SPC): Implement SPC techniques to monitor and control variability in the manufacturing process.
12. Identification and Control of Special Characteristics: Identify special characteristics of the product and process and implement appropriate control measures.
13. Risk Management: Assess and manage risks associated with the manufacturing process.
14. Continuous Improvement and Review: Continuously review and update the manufacturing process design input requirements based on data analysis, feedback, and lessons learned from previous projects. Implement a feedback loop to incorporate improvements and address changing requirements.

By following these steps and involving relevant stakeholders, the organization can ensure that the manufacturing process design input requirements are comprehensive, accurate, and aligned with customer needs and quality standards. Regular reviews and continuous improvement efforts further enhance the effectiveness and efficiency of the manufacturing process.

Manufacturing process design input requirements

Manufacturing process design input requirements play a crucial role in developing efficient and effective production processes. The following is a comprehensive list of input requirements that should be considered during manufacturing process design:

1. Product Design Output Data Including Special Characteristics: Product design output data, such as specifications, drawings, and requirements, provide essential information for designing the manufacturing process. Special characteristics identified during product design must be incorporated into the process design to ensure their proper control.
2. Targets for Productivity, Process Capability, Timing, and Cost: Set specific targets for productivity, process capability (e.g., Cp, Cpk), timing (cycle times, lead times), and cost to align the manufacturing process with overall business goals and customer expectations.
3. Manufacturing Technology Alternatives: Evaluate and consider different manufacturing technologies and methods to determine the most suitable approach for the product. This could include various processes like casting, machining, forming, welding, etc.
4. Customer Requirements, if Any: Take into account any specific customer requirements or preferences related to the manufacturing process or product characteristics.
5. Experience from Previous Developments: Draw from previous manufacturing process development experiences to identify best practices, lessons learned, and opportunities for improvement.
6. New Materials: If new materials are introduced in the product design, assess their compatibility with existing manufacturing processes or identify the need for new processes.
7. Product Handling and Ergonomic Requirements: Consider product handling requirements during manufacturing to ensure worker safety, reduce ergonomic risks, and optimize the efficiency of assembly and production tasks.
8. Design for Manufacturing (DFM) and Design for Assembly (DFA): Implement DFM and DFA principles during the process design to optimize manufacturability and ease of assembly, leading to cost-effective and efficient production.
9. Environmental Considerations: Incorporate environmental considerations and sustainable practices into the manufacturing process design to minimize waste and energy consumption.
10. Risk Assessment and Mitigation Strategies: Conduct a risk assessment of the manufacturing process and develop strategies to mitigate identified risks and challenges.
11. Quality Control Measures: Define quality control measures, inspection points, and testing protocols to ensure product quality and compliance with specifications.
12. Resource Allocation: Determine the necessary resources, equipment, tooling, and personnel required for the manufacturing process.
13. Process Validation Plan: Develop a plan for validating the manufacturing process to ensure it meets the defined targets and requirements.
14. Continuous Improvement Plan: Establish a plan for continuous improvement in the manufacturing process based on data analysis and feedback from production.

By addressing these manufacturing process design input requirements, automotive companies can develop robust and efficient production processes that result in high-quality products, meet customer demands, and remain competitive in the industry.

Use of error proofing method to be included in the manufacturing process design

Error-proofing, also known as Poka-Yoke, is a critical method used in manufacturing process design to prevent errors and defects before they occur or to detect them at an early stage. By incorporating error-proofing techniques, automotive companies can improve product quality, reduce rework, and enhance overall process efficiency. Here are some ways error-proofing can be included in the manufacturing process design:

1. Designing Foolproof Processes: Implementing foolproof processes that make it impossible or difficult to produce defects. For example, using a unique keying mechanism to ensure that parts can only be assembled in the correct orientation.
2. Using Sensors and Automation: Integrating sensors and automated systems to detect anomalies during production. Automated inspections can identify deviations from specifications and trigger alerts or stop the process when necessary.
3. Visual Management: Utilizing visual cues, such as color-coding or labels, to indicate correct assembly steps and part orientations, making it easier for operators to follow the correct procedures.
4. Checklists and Standard Operating Procedures (SOPs): Providing clear checklists and SOPs for operators to follow during each step of the manufacturing process to reduce the likelihood of errors.
5. Andon Systems: Implementing Andon systems that enable workers to quickly signal supervisors or support teams if they encounter a problem during production, allowing for immediate intervention.
6. Error Detection with Poka-Yoke Devices: Using Poka-Yoke devices, like sensors, limit switches, or mechanical fixtures, to identify defects or deviations from specifications, and stopping the process if an error is detected.
7. Error Prevention through Jidoka (Autonomation): Incorporating Jidoka principles to empower machines to stop themselves when they encounter an abnormality, preventing the production of defective parts.
8. Incorporating Error-Proofing in Design for Manufacturing (DFM): Ensuring that the product design includes features and characteristics that are easy to manufacture and assemble, reducing the likelihood of errors during production.
9. Training and Skill Development: Providing comprehensive training to operators and workers on error-proofing techniques and the importance of adhering to standardized processes.
10. Root Cause Analysis (RCA): Conducting regular root cause analyses of defects and errors to identify the underlying causes and implement corrective actions to prevent recurrence.
11. Continuous Improvement Culture: Fostering a culture of continuous improvement, where employees are encouraged to identify and propose error-proofing ideas and implement them throughout the manufacturing process.

By incorporating error-proofing methods into the manufacturing process design, automotive companies can significantly reduce defects, enhance product quality, increase customer satisfaction, and optimize their production efficiency. Error-proofing is an integral part of lean manufacturing and Total Quality Management (TQM) principles, leading to enhanced competitiveness and success in the automotive industry.

Click here for more on Poka-Yoke