IATF 16949:2016 Clause 10.3.1 Continual improvement

Continual improvement is defined as a recurring activity to increase the ability to fulfill requirements.  The ‘ability to fulfill requirements’ refers to both conforming as well as nonconforming processes. Conforming processes can be further improved; and nonconforming processes must be improved by taking corrective action to prevent recurrence. Recurring activity refers to the quality improvements – quality policy and objectives; audit results; analyses of data; etc. Continual improvement is only applicable to processes that are stable and capable (i.e. under control or conforming). It cannot be applied to nonconforming processes. Corrective action must first be taken to bring nonconforming (unstable or non-capable) processes under control, before any continual improvement can be done. The continual improvement process can be conducted by: Significant breakthrough projects that either revise or improve existing processes or lead to new processes. These are usually done by cross-functional teams outside routine operations. Small-step ongoing improvement activities conducted by personnel within existing processes. Use of continual improvement tools include:  Quality Policy and Quality objectives. Changes in product, customer base, organization ownership, management, technology, QMS standards, etc., may require changes to your quality policy and objectives. As a tool for continual improvement, it requires top management to review and understand these changes; make changes, if necessary, to the quality policy and objectives and use these changes to continue further improvement of the QMS and customer satisfaction. Audit Results – Results of product, process, process and QMS audits usually provide many opportunities to improve QMS effectiveness and efficiency. Opportunities may relate to communications; information systems; processes; controls; use of resources; technology; etc. The management representative must report these opportunities to top management as included as part of the management review agenda. They can also be reported and reviewed at regular operational meetings, etc. Other Audits – Besides product, process and QMS audits, you might find it very productive to conduct financial; health and safety; environmental; technology; product profitability; social responsibility; information and communication systems audits. You will be amazed at what you will find and improvement opportunities you will uncover. In using ‘analyses of data’ as a tool for continual improvement, use the TGR and TGW approach to classify your data for decision-making. Examples of situations which might lead to improvement projects include: machine set-up, die change, machine changeover times; cycle time; scrap; non value-added use of floor space; variation in product characteristics and process parameters; less than 100% first run capability; process averages not centered on target values; testing requirements not justified by accumulated results; waste of labor and materials; difficult manufacture, assembly and installation of product; excessive handling and storage; etc. Other tools that are often used to continually improve, include: capability studies; design of experiments; evaluation procedure; quality control chart system; risk analysis; SPC; supplier evaluation; test and measurement technology; theory of constraints; overall equipment effectiveness; parts per million (ppm) to achieve zero defects; value analysis; benchmarking; analysis of motion/ergonomics and error-proofing. Ensure that personnel applying these tools are competent and trained Use SPC, new material, tooling, equipment or technology to control and reduce variation in product characteristics and process parameters. Document improvements in drawings, FMEA, control plans, work instructions, etc., and update PPAP. Performance indicators to measure the effectiveness of the continual improvement process may include – quality objectives being met sooner than planned;; achieving and exceeding business and quality objectives; improved efficiency in use of resources; cost reduction; improved product quality; increased Cpk’s; etc.  

Clause 10.3.1 Continual improvement

In addition to the requirement given in Clause 10.3 Continual improvement , Clause 10.3.1 requires that the organization to have a documented process for continual improvement which shall include identification of the methodology used, objectives, measurement, effectiveness, and documented information; a manufacturing process improvement action plan with emphasis on the reduction of process variation and waste; and risk analysis (such as FMEA). Continual improvement is implemented once manufacturing processes are statistically capable and stable or when product characteristics are predictable and meet customer requirements

Continual improvement is implemented once manufacturing processes are statistically capable and stable or when product characteristics are predictable and meet customer requirements. “Statistically capable” refers to processes that have achieved a level of capability where the variation in their outputs is within acceptable limits. This means that the process is predictable and can consistently produce products that meet specifications. “Stable” processes are those that exhibit consistent and predictable behavior over time, with minimal variability. Stability indicates that the process is under control and not subject to significant fluctuations. In essence, the organization should focus on establishing a solid foundation of stable and capable processes, ensuring that products consistently meet customer requirements. Once this foundation is established, the organization can then shift its focus to continual improvement, seeking ways to further optimize processes, enhance product quality, reduce waste, and achieve higher levels of efficiency and customer satisfaction.This approach aligns with the principles of quality management, including those outlined in IATF 16949, and emphasizes the importance of basing improvement efforts on a solid understanding of process capability, stability, and customer needs. It ensures that improvements are built upon a strong and reliable manufacturing foundation, leading to sustainable and meaningful enhancements.

Having a documented process for continual improvement is a fundamental aspect of an effective quality management system, aligned with standards such as IATF 16949. This process provides a structured framework for identifying, prioritizing, implementing, and evaluating improvements across various aspects of the organization. Here’s how you can establish a documented process for continual improvement:

  1. Process Definition and Scope: Clearly define the scope of the continual improvement process. Determine which areas, processes, and functions within the organization will be subject to improvement efforts.
  2. Leadership Commitment: Obtain commitment and support from top management to ensure that the organization is dedicated to driving continual improvement as a core value.
  3. Cross-Functional Teams: Establish cross-functional improvement teams that include representatives from different departments. These teams will collaborate on identifying and implementing improvement opportunities.
  4. Identification of Improvement Opportunities: Develop a systematic approach for identifying improvement opportunities. This could involve analyzing customer feedback, performance metrics, audits, internal assessments, and benchmarking.
  5. Prioritization and Selection: Evaluate and prioritize the identified improvement opportunities based on factors such as potential impact, feasibility, resource availability, and alignment with strategic goals.
  6. Action Planning: Create detailed action plans for selected improvement initiatives. Specify objectives, strategies, timelines, responsibilities, and required resources for each improvement project.
  7. Implementation and Execution: Execute the action plans, making necessary changes to processes, procedures, or systems. Engage the relevant teams and stakeholders to ensure smooth implementation.
  8. Monitoring and Measurement: Establish key performance indicators (KPIs) to measure the progress and effectiveness of improvement initiatives. Regularly monitor and measure results against established targets.
  9. Review and Evaluation: Conduct periodic reviews of improvement projects to assess their outcomes, identify any deviations, and determine if the desired improvements have been achieved.
  10. Learning and Knowledge Sharing: Encourage a culture of learning and knowledge sharing within the organization. Ensure that insights gained from improvement projects are communicated across teams and departments.
  11. Documentation and Records: Document all aspects of the continual improvement process, including improvement plans, actions taken, results achieved, lessons learned, and any changes made.
  12. Feedback Mechanisms: Establish mechanisms for collecting feedback from employees, customers, and other stakeholders on improvement initiatives. Use feedback to refine processes and drive further enhancements.
  13. Training and Skill Development: Provide training to employees involved in the continual improvement process. Equip them with problem-solving skills, data analysis techniques, and tools for process enhancement.
  14. Integration with Quality Management System: Integrate the continual improvement process with the organization’s overall quality management system. Ensure alignment with other processes such as corrective action, preventive action, and risk management.
  15. Communication and Reporting: Communicate the progress and results of improvement initiatives to all relevant stakeholders. Share success stories and lessons learned to inspire and motivate the organization.

Having a documented process for continual improvement demonstrates your organization’s commitment to achieving excellence, driving innovation, and delivering value to customers. This structured approach helps foster a culture of continuous learning and enhancement, ultimately leading to sustained growth and improved competitiveness.

Methodology for Continual improvement

The process for the identification of the methodology used, objectives, measurement, effectiveness, and documented information in the context of continual improvement is a structured approach to ensure that improvement initiatives are well-defined, measurable, and result in meaningful enhancements. Determine the methodology or approach to be used for the specific improvement initiative. This could include established methodologies like Six Sigma, Lean, PDCA (Plan-Do-Check-Act), DMAIC (Define-Measure-Analyze-Improve-Control), or other suitable frameworks. Define clear and specific objectives for the improvement initiative. What do you aim to achieve through this improvement? Objectives should be aligned with the organization’s strategic goals and customer requirements. Establish measurement criteria or key performance indicators (KPIs) that will be used to assess the success of the improvement initiative. These criteria should be quantifiable, measurable, and relevant to the objectives. Determine how the effectiveness of the improvement initiative will be evaluated. This could involve assessing factors such as cost reduction, cycle time improvement, defect reduction, customer satisfaction enhancement, etc. Create and maintain documented information related to the improvement initiative. This includes action plans, process maps, data analysis, reports, and any other relevant documentation. Involve cross-functional teams in the process to ensure diverse perspectives and expertise. Collaborate with different departments to gather insights and input. Develop a detailed action plan outlining the steps, responsibilities, timelines, and resources required to implement the improvement initiative. Execute the action plan according to the defined methodology. Monitor progress and ensure that tasks are carried out as planned. Collect relevant data and measurements according to the established measurement criteria and KPIs. Use data analysis tools to assess the current state and identify areas for improvement. Evaluate the effectiveness of the improvement initiative based on the measurement criteria. Compare the results to the objectives to determine the level of success achieved. Document the results of the improvement initiative, including before-and-after data, analysis findings, lessons learned, and any challenges encountered. Encourage a culture of continuous learning by sharing insights and experiences gained from the improvement initiative. Use this knowledge to inform future improvement projects. Review the documented information and results with relevant stakeholders. Gather feedback on the process, outcomes, and potential areas for further enhancement. Communicate the outcomes and benefits of the improvement initiative to internal teams and, when applicable, to customers or other external parties. Integrate the methodology identification, objectives, measurement, and effectiveness evaluation into the broader continual improvement process of the organization. By following this process, your organization can ensure that improvement initiatives are well-defined, effectively executed, and result in measurable enhancements that contribute to the organization’s overall goals and success.

Manufacturing process improvement action plan

Incorporating a manufacturing process improvement action plan with a focus on reducing process variation and waste is a proactive step towards enhancing product quality, efficiency, and overall operational excellence. Begin by conducting a thorough assessment of the current manufacturing process. Identify areas where process variation and waste are prominent and affecting product quality, lead times, and resource utilization. Clearly define the objectives of the improvement action plan. Specify the desired outcomes, such as target levels of process variation reduction and waste reduction, and how these align with overall organizational goals. Establish a cross-functional team consisting of experts from different departments, including manufacturing, quality, engineering, and operations. This team will collaborate to design and implement the improvement plan. Collect relevant data on process parameters, variations, defects, and waste generation. Utilize statistical tools and techniques to analyze the data and identify root causes of process variation and waste.Perform a thorough root cause analysis to understand the underlying factors contributing to process variation and waste. Use tools such as fishbone diagrams, Pareto charts, and 5 Whys to identify key factors. Based on the root cause analysis, work with the cross-functional team to redesign and optimize the manufacturing process. Implement changes that reduce sources of variation and waste, and enhance process stability. Implement a system for continuous monitoring and measurement of process parameters, variation levels, and waste generation. Use real-time data to track progress and ensure that improvements are sustained. Standardize the improved process by documenting standard operating procedures (SOPs) and providing training to relevant personnel. Ensure that everyone is aligned with the new process. Integrate quality control measures, such as in-process inspections and quality gates, to detect and address process variations early in the production cycle. Implement waste reduction strategies such as lean principles, 5S (Sort, Set in order, Shine, Standardize, Sustain), and visual management techniques to systematically eliminate waste from the process. Foster a culture of continuous improvement where employees are encouraged to identify and address process variations and waste in their daily work. Provide incentives for innovative ideas and contributions. Establish key performance indicators (KPIs) to measure the success of the improvement action plan. Regularly report progress and outcomes to management and relevant stakeholders. Encourage feedback from employees involved in the process and gather their insights on further improvements. Use lessons learned to refine the process and drive further enhancements. Document all steps of the improvement action plan, including data analysis, root cause findings, process changes, and results achieved. Communicate the plan and outcomes across the organization. Periodically review the effectiveness of the improvement action plan. Make adjustments based on new insights, changing conditions, or shifts in organizational priorities. By implementing a manufacturing process improvement action plan with a focus on reducing process variation and waste, your organization can achieve significant gains in product quality, cost efficiency, and customer satisfaction. This approach aligns with the principles of continual improvement and contributes to the organization’s long-term success.

Risk Analysis:

Integrating risk analysis, such as Failure Mode and Effects Analysis (FMEA), into the continual improvement process enhances your organization’s ability to proactively identify and mitigate potential risks, thereby ensuring more robust and sustainable improvements. As you identify areas for improvement within your processes, products, or systems, also consider potential risks associated with these areas. This can include risks related to process variation, waste, quality, safety, and customer satisfaction.Create a cross-functional team comprising experts from different disciplines. This team will collaborate to perform the FMEA as part of the continual improvement process. Define the scope of the FMEA. Identify the specific process, product, or system that will be analyzed. Clearly outline the boundaries and interfaces of the analysis. List all possible failure modes that could occur within the scope of the analysis. These failure modes represent potential risks or issues that may impact the desired improvement. Evaluate the potential effects or consequences of each identified failure mode. Consider how each failure mode could impact product quality, customer satisfaction, safety, and other critical factors. Assign a severity rating to each failure mode based on the potential impact. Use a predefined scale to rate the severity, with higher ratings indicating more severe consequences. Determine the root causes of each failure mode. Understand why these failure modes might occur and what factors contribute to their occurrence. Assign an occurrence rating to each failure mode to represent the likelihood of its occurrence. Use data, historical records, and expert judgment to determine the likelihood. Assign a detection rating to each failure mode, indicating how likely the failure mode is to be detected before reaching the customer. Lower detection ratings signify a higher likelihood of the failure going undetected. Calculate the Risk Priority Numbers (RPNs) for each failure mode by multiplying severity, occurrence, and detection ratings. Prioritize the failure modes based on their RPNs. Develop mitigation and control measures for high-priority failure modes with elevated RPNs. These measures aim to reduce the severity, occurrence, or improve detection of potential issues. Implement the identified mitigation measures and monitor their effectiveness over time. Adjust and refine the measures as needed based on real-world results. Document the entire FMEA process, including failure modes, severity, occurrence, detection ratings, RPNs, root causes, and mitigation actions taken. Communicate the outcomes and actions to relevant stakeholders. Gather feedback from the team and stakeholders on the effectiveness of the FMEA-based improvements. Use this feedback to refine the continual improvement process and future FMEA analyses Integrate the outcomes of the FMEA into your broader continual improvement initiatives. Use the insights gained from FMEA to guide improvement efforts and ensure that risks are proactively addressed. By incorporating risk analysis like FMEA into the continual improvement process, your organization can identify potential risks early, implement effective control measures, and drive more robust and sustainable improvements. This approach aligns with the principles of quality management and contributes to overall organizational resilience and excellence.

Leave a Reply