ISO 14001:2015 Clause 10.1 Improvement -General

10.1 General

The organization shall determine opportunities for improvement (see 9.1, 9.2 and 9.3) and implement necessary actions to achieve the intended outcomes of its environmental management system.

1) Identifying opportunity for improvement from clause 9.1 Monitoring, measurement, analysis and evaluation

Clause 9.1 of ISO 14001:2015, titled “Monitoring, measurement, analysis, and evaluation,” is a critical part of the Environmental Management System (EMS) standard. It provides organizations with a framework for assessing their environmental performance and identifying opportunities for improvement. Here’s how an organization can identify opportunities for improvement from Clause 9.1:

  1. Understand the Requirements: Begin by thoroughly understanding the requirements of Clause 9.1. Familiarize yourself with the specific sub-clauses and their objectives. This clause covers various aspects, including the establishment of performance indicators, monitoring, measurement, and evaluation of compliance.
  2. Define Performance Indicators: Establish clear and relevant environmental performance indicators (KPIs) that align with your organization’s environmental objectives and targets. These indicators should be measurable and reflect key environmental aspects and impacts.
  3. Implement Monitoring and Measurement: Implement a robust system for monitoring and measuring environmental performance against the established indicators. This involves collecting data on a regular basis and ensuring that it is accurate and reliable.
  4. Analyze Data: Once you have collected data, perform data analysis to identify trends, patterns, and areas of concern. Look for deviations from established targets and objectives. Data analysis tools and techniques, such as statistical analysis or trend analysis, can be useful.
  5. Evaluate Compliance: Evaluate your organization’s compliance with legal and other requirements related to environmental aspects. Identify any instances of non-compliance or potential compliance risks.
  6. Assess Objectives and Targets: Review your environmental objectives and targets set in Clause 6.2 to determine whether they are being met. If not, analyze the reasons behind any shortfalls.
  7. Identify Trends and Areas for Improvement: Based on the data analysis and compliance evaluation, identify trends that indicate areas where your organization could improve its environmental performance. Look for opportunities to reduce environmental impacts, enhance resource efficiency, and minimize risks.
  8. Engage Stakeholders: Involve relevant stakeholders, including employees, suppliers, customers, and regulatory authorities, in the evaluation process. Their input and feedback can provide valuable insights into areas for improvement.
  9. Document Findings: Document the findings of your analysis, including identified opportunities for improvement and any corrective actions required to address non-compliance or performance shortfalls. This documentation is essential for tracking progress and demonstrating your commitment to continuous improvement.
  10. Set Priorities: Prioritize the identified opportunities for improvement based on their significance and potential impact on the environment. Consider the feasibility of implementing changes and allocate resources accordingly.
  11. Implement Improvement Actions: Develop and implement action plans to address the identified opportunities for improvement. These action plans should include specific tasks, responsibilities, timelines, and resources needed.
  12. Monitor Progress: Continuously monitor the progress of improvement actions and track their effectiveness. Adjust the plans as needed to ensure that improvements are achieved.
  13. Review and Repeat: During management reviews (Clause 9.3), evaluate the effectiveness of the EMS, including the progress made in addressing opportunities for improvement. This review should lead to further refinements and adjustments in your EMS.

By following these steps, an organization can effectively identify and capitalize on opportunities for improvement as required by Clause 9.1 of ISO 14001. This process contributes to the ongoing enhancement of environmental performance and compliance within the organization.

2) Identifying opportunity for improvement from clause 9.2 Internal audit

Clause 9.2 of ISO 14001:2015 pertains to the internal audit process within an Environmental Management System (EMS). Conducting internal audits is a crucial step in ensuring the effectiveness of your EMS and identifying opportunities for improvement. Here’s how an organization can identify opportunities for improvement from Clause 9.2, “Internal audit”:

  1. Understand the Requirements: Begin by understanding the specific requirements outlined in Clause 9.2. This clause sets out the expectations for planning, conducting, and reporting on internal audits of the EMS.
  2. Establish an Audit Schedule: Develop a well-defined audit schedule that covers all relevant areas of your EMS. This schedule should include audit frequencies, areas to be audited, and responsible auditors.
  3. Select Competent Auditors: Ensure that your internal auditors are competent and impartial. They should have a good understanding of ISO 14001, your organization’s EMS, and environmental aspects and impacts.
  4. Plan the Audit: Before conducting internal audits, carefully plan the scope, objectives, and criteria for each audit. Consider the areas of the EMS that need to be audited, including processes, procedures, and documentation.
  5. Conduct the Audit: During the audit, auditors should follow the audit plan, conduct interviews, review documents, and gather evidence to assess the conformity and effectiveness of the EMS. Look for deviations from the requirements and areas that might benefit from improvement.
  6. Document Findings: Document all audit findings, including non-conformities, observations, and opportunities for improvement. Ensure that findings are specific, clear, and supported by evidence.
  7. Analyze Findings: After the audit, analyze the findings to identify trends or recurring issues. Pay attention to systemic issues that may indicate broader problems within the EMS.
  8. Identify Opportunities for Improvement: Opportunities for improvement can be identified in various ways during the audit process:
    • Non-conformities: These are instances where your EMS does not meet the ISO 14001 requirements. Correcting these non-conformities is a clear opportunity for improvement.
    • Observations: These are areas where the EMS might not be fully optimized, even if it complies with the standard. Auditors can suggest improvements based on their observations.
    • Best Practices: Auditors might come across practices within your organization that are particularly effective or efficient. These can be adopted elsewhere in the EMS.
  9. Report Audit Findings: Prepare an audit report that summarizes the findings, including non-conformities and opportunities for improvement. Ensure that the report is communicated to relevant personnel and management.
  10. Take Corrective and Preventive Actions: Address non-conformities identified during the audit through corrective actions. For opportunities for improvement, develop action plans to make enhancements to the EMS. Assign responsibilities, set timelines, and allocate resources.
  11. Implement Improvement Actions: Put the improvement actions into practice, making necessary changes to processes, procedures, or documentation.
  12. Monitor Progress: Continuously monitor the progress of improvement actions and track their effectiveness. Ensure that they result in the desired outcomes.
  13. Review and Repeat: During management reviews (Clause 9.3), evaluate the effectiveness of the internal audit process and the actions taken to address opportunities for improvement. Make necessary adjustments to your EMS to further enhance its performance.

By following these steps, an organization can use the internal audit process required by Clause 9.2 of ISO 14001 to systematically identify and address opportunities for improvement within its Environmental Management System, leading to enhanced environmental performance and compliance.

3) Identify opportunity for improvement from 9.3 Management review

Clause 9.3 of ISO 14001:2015 focuses on the management review process within an Environmental Management System (EMS). This process plays a vital role in assessing the overall effectiveness of the EMS and identifying opportunities for improvement. Here’s how an organization can identify opportunities for improvement from Clause 9.3, “Management review”:

  1. Understand the Requirements: Begin by thoroughly understanding the specific requirements outlined in Clause 9.3. This clause details the expectations for conducting management reviews of the EMS.
  2. Schedule Regular Reviews: Establish a regular schedule for management reviews. The frequency of these reviews should be defined in your EMS and take into account the organization’s size, complexity, and environmental risks.
  3. Select Key Participants: Invite key participants to the management review, including top management, relevant department heads, and individuals with knowledge of the EMS and environmental performance.
  4. Prepare for the Review: Prepare relevant documentation and data in advance of the management review meeting. This should include performance data, audit findings, compliance status, customer feedback, and information on environmental objectives and targets.
  5. Conduct the Management Review Meeting: During the review meeting, discuss various aspects of the EMS and its performance, such as:
    • Compliance with legal and other requirements (Clause 9.1)
    • Environmental aspects and impacts (Clause 6.1.2)
    • Environmental objectives and targets (Clause 6.2)
    • Results of internal audits (Clause 9.2)
    • Opportunities for improvement identified during audits and other assessments
    • Effectiveness of corrective and preventive actions
    • Changes in the organization’s context that may affect the EMS
  6. Assess Effectiveness: Evaluate the effectiveness of the EMS in meeting its intended outcomes and objectives. This assessment should include a consideration of the organization’s environmental performance against its targets and goals.
  7. Identify Opportunities for Improvement: Opportunities for improvement can be identified during the management review process through several means:
    • Review of Data: Analyze performance data and indicators to identify trends or deviations from targets.
    • Discussion: Engage in open discussions during the review meeting to surface issues and potential improvements.
    • Feedback: Consider feedback from employees, customers, and other stakeholders regarding environmental matters.
  8. Document Findings: Document the findings of the management review, including any identified opportunities for improvement. These findings should be specific, actionable, and supported by evidence.
  9. Prioritize and Assign Responsibility: Prioritize the opportunities for improvement based on their significance and potential impact on environmental performance. Assign responsibility for each improvement initiative to the appropriate personnel or teams.
  10. Develop Action Plans: Create action plans for addressing the identified opportunities for improvement. These plans should outline specific steps, timelines, and resource allocations.
  11. Implement Improvement Actions: Put the improvement actions into practice, making necessary changes to processes, procedures, or documentation.
  12. Monitor Progress: Continuously monitor the progress of improvement actions and track their effectiveness. Ensure that they result in the desired outcomes.
  13. Review and Repeat: In subsequent management reviews, evaluate the effectiveness of the actions taken to address opportunities for improvement. Make necessary adjustments to the EMS and its objectives and targets.

By following these steps, an organization can use the management review process required by Clause 9.3 of ISO 14001 to systematically identify and address opportunities for improvement within its Environmental Management System. This contributes to the ongoing enhancement of environmental performance and compliance while aligning with the principles of continuous improvement.

The organization shall determine opportunities for improvement and implement necessary actions to achieve the intended outcomes of its environmental management system.

It emphasizes the importance of continuous improvement within an organization’s EMS. To fulfill this requirement effectively, an organization should follow these steps:

  1. Contextual Understanding: Begin by understanding your organization’s context. This involves identifying internal and external factors that can affect your environmental performance, such as regulatory changes, market trends, stakeholder expectations, and internal capabilities.
  2. Environmental Aspects and Impacts: Determine your organization’s environmental aspects and impacts. These are the activities, products, and services that can interact with the environment and cause environmental effects. Assess the significance of each aspect in terms of its potential impact on the environment.
  3. Legal and Other Requirements: Identify and understand the legal and other requirements that apply to your organization’s environmental aspects. Compliance with these requirements is essential to prevent non-conformities and regulatory issues.
  4. Environmental Objectives and Targets: Establish environmental objectives and targets based on your understanding of environmental aspects, impacts, and legal requirements. These objectives should be specific, measurable, achievable, relevant, and time-bound (SMART).
  5. Performance Monitoring: Implement a robust monitoring and measurement system (as per Clause 9.1 of ISO 14001) to track your environmental performance. Use key performance indicators (KPIs) to quantify your progress toward achieving objectives and targets.
  6. Internal Auditing: Conduct regular internal audits (as per Clause 9.2 of ISO 14001) to assess the conformity of your EMS and its effectiveness. Auditors can help identify areas where improvement is needed.
  7. Management Review: Hold management review meetings (as per Clause 9.3 of ISO 14001) at defined intervals, typically annually, to evaluate the overall performance of the EMS, including the progress made towards objectives and targets. These reviews can reveal opportunities for improvement.
  8. Employee Engagement: Involve employees at all levels in the identification of opportunities for improvement. They often have valuable insights into daily operations and potential improvements.
  9. Stakeholder Engagement: Engage with external stakeholders, such as customers, suppliers, regulatory authorities, and the community, to gather feedback and insights on environmental matters.
  10. Root Cause Analysis: When issues or non-conformities arise, use root cause analysis techniques (e.g., Fishbone diagram, 5 Whys) to dig deeper into the underlying causes. This can help identify systemic issues that require corrective and preventive actions.
  11. Action Planning: Develop action plans to address identified opportunities for improvement. These plans should include specific steps, responsibilities, timelines, and resource allocations.
  12. Implementation: Put the improvement actions into practice, making necessary changes to processes, procedures, or documentation.
  13. Monitoring Progress: Continuously monitor the progress of improvement actions and track their effectiveness. Adjust plans as needed to ensure that improvements are achieved.
  14. Documentation and Records: Maintain accurate records of the entire improvement process, from identification through implementation and verification.
  15. Review and Repeat: In subsequent management reviews and audits, evaluate the effectiveness of the actions taken to address opportunities for improvement. Make necessary adjustments to the EMS and its objectives and targets to ensure continuous improvement.

By following these steps, an organization can systematically identify and implement actions to improve the effectiveness and performance of its Environmental Management System, ultimately achieving its intended outcomes and demonstrating a commitment to environmental sustainability.

Documented Information required

The clause outlines the requirements for documenting and recording improvement-related activities within an Environmental Management System (EMS). Here are the documents and records required in Clause 10.1:

Documents :

  1. Improvement Procedure: An organization should have documented procedures for managing improvement-related activities within the EMS. This procedure outlines the steps for identifying, evaluating, implementing, and monitoring opportunities for improvement.
  2. Opportunity for Improvement Register: Maintain a documented register or log to track identified opportunities for improvement. This register should include details such as the nature of the opportunity, its significance, responsible individuals or teams, and status.
  3. Action Plans: Documented action plans are required for addressing identified opportunities for improvement. These plans should include specific actions, responsibilities, timelines, resource allocation, and measurable objectives.
  4. Progress Reports: Documented progress reports should be maintained to track the implementation of improvement actions. These reports should include information on milestones achieved, deviations, and any corrective actions taken during the implementation.

Records:

  1. Records of Opportunity Identification: Maintain records of the opportunities for improvement identified within your EMS. This includes documentation of the sources, methods, and dates of identification.
  2. Records of Opportunity Evaluation: Document the evaluation of identified opportunities for improvement. Include information on the significance assessment, criteria used for prioritization, and rationale for their selection.
  3. Action Plan Records: Records of action plans developed to address opportunities for improvement should be maintained. These records should detail the specific actions, responsibilities, timelines, and resource allocation.
  4. Progress Monitoring Records: Keep records of the progress made in implementing improvement actions. These records should include updates, deviations, corrective actions taken, and any changes to the original action plan.
  5. Results and Outcomes Records: Document the results and outcomes of the improvement actions, including any measurable improvements in environmental performance, compliance, resource efficiency, or other relevant areas.
  6. Verification and Validation Records: If applicable, maintain records of verification and validation activities conducted to confirm the effectiveness of improvement actions.
  7. Records of Lessons Learned: Document lessons learned from addressing opportunities for improvement. These records can be valuable for future improvement efforts and should include insights, best practices, and areas for further enhancement.
  8. Management Review Records: Summarize the status and effectiveness of improvement activities in records presented during management review meetings (Clause 9.3).
  9. Training and Competence Records: If additional training or competence development is required for personnel involved in improvement activities, maintain records of training sessions, competencies achieved, and training materials.
  10. Communication Records: Document any internal and external communications related to identified opportunities for improvement and their outcomes.
  11. Records of Closure: When an opportunity for improvement has been successfully addressed and its objectives met, maintain records of closure, including evidence of compliance with the action plan and objectives.
  12. Audit Records: Records of internal audits (Clause 9.2) may include findings related to opportunities for improvement. These findings and any related corrective actions should be documented.
  13. Communication Records with External Parties: Document any communication with external stakeholders, such as regulatory authorities, related to opportunities for improvement and their resolution.

Example for Procedure for Identifying and Addressing Opportunities for Improvement in the EMS

Objective: The objective of this procedure is to systematically identify, evaluate, and address opportunities for improvement within the organization’s Environmental Management System (EMS) to enhance environmental performance and compliance.

Scope: This procedure applies to all activities, processes, and functions within the organization’s EMS.

Responsibilities:

  1. Environmental Management Representative (EMR): The EMR is responsible for overall coordination and oversight of the procedure.
  2. Environmental Team: A cross-functional environmental team, consisting of relevant department heads and key personnel, is responsible for identifying and evaluating opportunities for improvement.

Procedure:

  1. Identification of Opportunities for Improvement:a. The environmental team periodically reviews the organization’s EMS and associated documentation, including the environmental policy, objectives, and targets.b. The team considers inputs from various sources, including:
    • Internal audit reports (Clause 9.2)
    • Management review findings (Clause 9.3)
    • Employee suggestions and feedback
    • Environmental performance data and trends
    • Regulatory changes and updates
    c. The team conducts brainstorming sessions or meetings to identify areas where improvements can be made in environmental performance, compliance, efficiency, or sustainability.d. Opportunities for improvement may include:
    • Reducing resource consumption
    • Enhancing waste reduction and recycling efforts
    • Improving energy efficiency
    • Strengthening compliance with legal requirements
    • Enhancing communication and stakeholder engagement
    • Identifying new environmental objectives and targets
  2. Evaluation of Opportunities:a. The environmental team evaluates each identified opportunity for improvement based on criteria such as:
    • Significance of potential environmental impact
    • Alignment with organizational goals and objectives
    • Feasibility of implementation
    • Potential benefits, including cost savings, reduced risk, or improved reputation
    b. Each opportunity is documented, including its description, potential impact, and rationale for evaluation.
  3. Prioritization:a. The environmental team prioritizes opportunities for improvement based on their significance, potential benefits, and feasibility.b. Opportunities are categorized into:
    • High priority (urgent and significant)
    • Medium priority (important but not urgent)
    • Low priority (worth considering in the long term)
  4. Action Planning:a. For high-priority opportunities, the team develops detailed action plans that include:
    • Specific tasks and responsibilities
    • Timelines for completion
    • Resource allocation
    • Performance indicators and measures
    b. Action plans are reviewed and approved by top management.
  5. Implementation:a. The identified improvement actions are implemented according to the approved action plans.b. Employees responsible for specific tasks are informed, trained, and provided with necessary resources.
  6. Monitoring and Review:a. Progress toward achieving the identified improvements is monitored regularly.b. Key performance indicators and measures are tracked to assess the effectiveness of the improvement actions.c. The environmental team conducts periodic reviews to evaluate the success of implemented actions.
  7. Documentation and Reporting:a. All activities related to identifying, evaluating, and addressing opportunities for improvement are documented, including the rationale, action plans, progress reports, and outcomes.b. A summary of opportunities for improvement and their status is provided to top management during management review meetings (Clause 9.3).
  8. Feedback and Continual Improvement:a. Feedback on the effectiveness of implemented improvement actions is sought from relevant stakeholders, including employees, regulatory authorities, and customers.b. Lessons learned from addressing opportunities for improvement are documented and used to enhance the organization’s EMS and future improvement efforts.
  9. Closure: Once an opportunity for improvement has been successfully addressed and its objectives met, it is closed, and the documentation is retained for reference.

This procedure should be reviewed and updated periodically to ensure its continued effectiveness in identifying and addressing opportunities for improvement within the EMS.

Leave a Reply